| There
will be 12 judges divided in to 4 judging panels, each panel
will also include 1 guest judge from the wine media, this
judge will be apart of evaluating and discussing each wine
but judging scores will not be included in final results.
Each panel will be supported by a volunteer Panel Secretary
that will record all results and keep all records.
Panels
are created in an attempt to put judges on panels that reflect
their expertise – for example Pinot Noir critics, winemakers
and growers judge Pinot Noir, where possible.
The
wines are divided into flights of similar wines - for example,
dessert-style whites or 2001 Sangiovese. Each flight is evaluated
by one judging panel. The wines are poured into glasses in
a separate room from the judges, so that they do not know
anything about the wine.
The
Wine Competition is judged on a verbal consensus system: each
wine is judged using a zero to four point system, roughly
0= no award, 1 = bronze, 2 = silver, 3 = gold, 4 = double
gold. For each wine, all four judges give their score verbally
to the Panel Secretary; if the result is clear, the medal
is awarded to the wine immediately. If the result is not clear,
the Panel Secretary opens a discussion by asking the judge
who awarded the highest score to explain why they like the
wine. Once a consensus is reached, the medal, if any, is awarded.
Panel
Chairs can ask for a re-pour of any wine, and panel members
can request a re-pour through their Panel Chair. The Panel
Chair’s decision about a re-pour is final. A panel member
can also open a discussion if they have a strong feeling that
a wine is corked or the bottle is seriously flawed or “off”.
All
wines are opened no less than 15, and no more than 30, minutes
before serving.
All wines are presented at cool room temperature – around
65 degrees Fahrenheit.
All wines are given the same “breathing time”,
the same amount is poured into glasses and every glass is
cleaned and polished before pouring. Crystal wine glasses
are used for the competition.
Wines are put into flights according to varietal. The Wine
Competition Director decides how they will be grouped. We
avoid pairing wines with different varietal or different sugar
content.
|